31 old bay seasoning substitute Recipes

  • All Purpose House Seasoning
    kosher salt , do not substitute table salt and
    5 More
    kosher salt , do not substitute table salt, cracked black pepper, substitute with ground pepper reduce to 1 tbsp, instant minced onion, crushed, celery seed, instant minced garlic, crushed, old bay seasoning
    5 min, 6 ingredients
  • Crab Rice
    coarsely-chopped imitation crabmeat (the spices in this d... and
    8 More
    coarsely-chopped imitation crabmeat (the spices in this dish will over power the delicate taste of real crab, but you can still use if yo), shrimp (peeled and deveined and coarsely chopped ), baby shrimp, onion, chopped, chopped bell pepper (any color ), spanish rice mix (such as rice-a-roni), salt and pepper, old bay seasoning (don tsp substitute), olive oil
    30 min, 9 ingredients
  • Tuna Burgers
    tuna in water, fresh breadcrumbs (or canned ) and
    12 More
    tuna in water, fresh breadcrumbs (or canned ), pickle relish, egg beaters egg substitute or 1 egg, pimiento (optional), green onion (chopped ), celery (chopped ), light mayonnaise, dijon mustard, old bay seasoning (or i use extra old bay!) (optional), tabasco sauce (optional), green pepper, chopped (optional), cheddar cheese (thin slice, optional ) (optional) or 4 -5 slices soy cheese (thin slice) (optional), hamburger bun
    25 min, 14 ingredients
  • Crab Stuffed Orange Roughy
    butter-flavored cooking spray, seasoned dry bread crumb and
    17 More
    butter-flavored cooking spray, seasoned dry bread crumb, egg substitute, chopped sweet onions, chopped red bell peppers or 2 tbsp green bell peppers, cajun seasoning or 2 tsp old bay seasoning, dried mustard, dried parsley, hot red pepper sauce, backfin lump crabmeat, divided use, orange roughy fillets (approximately 6 oz each), fresh lemon juice or 1/2 small lemon juice, from, paprika, light margarine (45 calories per tablespoon), green onions, chopped, white wine, low sodium chicken broth, flour, ground black pepper
    55 min, 19 ingredients
  • Quick Salmon Patties
    boneless and skinless canned salmon (pink or red ) and
    8 More
    boneless and skinless canned salmon (pink or red ), crushed low-fat saltine crackers, egg substitute, old bay seasoning, chopped fresh parsley (, or 1 tsp. dried ), black pepper, canola oil or olive oil, lemon wedge, tartar sauce
    11 min, 9 ingredients
  • Crab And Shrimp Cakes
    egg substitute, light mayonnaise and
    12 More
    egg substitute, light mayonnaise, fresh ground black pepper, cayenne pepper, paprika, dry mustard, crushed celery seed, old bay seasoning, worcestershire sauce, lump crab meat, cooked shrimp, finely chopped, chopped yellow onion, bread crumbs, grapeseed oil for frying
    15 min, 14 ingredients
  • Crab Quiche Florentine
    refrigerated breadstick dough, grated gruyere cheese and
    10 More
    refrigerated breadstick dough, grated gruyere cheese, lump crabmeat, shell pieces removed and drained, chopped onion, coarsely chopped spinach, dried tarragon, old bay seasoning, ground nutmeg, pepper, evaporated skim milk, egg substitute, tomatoes, quartered (optional)
    13 ingredients
  • Crispy Oven Baked Tilapia
    tilapia fillets, panko bread crumbs, all purpose flour and
    7 More
    tilapia fillets, panko bread crumbs, all purpose flour, grated parmesean cheese, egg substitute, milk, old bay seasoning, olive oil, lemon juice
    10 ingredients
  • Crab Cakes - Lightened Up
    light mayonnaise and
    18 More
    light mayonnaise, green onions, finely minced (green part only ), red bell peppers, finely minced, yellow mustard, parsley, finely minced, egg substitute, old bay seasoning, lump crabmeat, plain breadcrumbs, panko breadcrumbs (japanese bread crumbs), light mayonnaise, dill pickles, chopped, fresh lemon juice, fresh parsley, finely minced, paprika, chili powder, cayenne powder, ground cumin, salt
    45 min, 19 ingredients
  • Old Bay Seasoned Tuna Cakes Old Bay Seasoned Tuna Cakes
    chunk light tuna, red bell pepper, diced and
    4 More
    chunk light tuna, red bell pepper, diced, egg beaters egg substitute, breadcrumbs (plain ), old bay seasoning, onion, minced
    20 min, 6 ingredients
  • Old Bay Seasoning  Substitute Old Bay Seasoning Substitute
    celery seed, black peppercorns, dried bay leaves and
    6 More
    celery seed, black peppercorns, dried bay leaves, cardamom seed, mustard seeds (optional), hungarian paprika, mace or 1/4 tsp nutmeg, salt
    10 min, 9 ingredients
  • Savory Sausage Quick Skillet Savory Sausage Quick Skillet
    cooked italian sausage (about 4) and
    12 More
    cooked italian sausage (about 4), chopped zucchini (a small tender 1), frozen sweet corn, canned red kidney beans, olive oil, instant minced onion (dry spice or fresh chopped), old bay seasoning (substitute ( celery salt, red & black pepper), garlic powder, paprika, grain brown rice (i like trader joe s medley), water, beef bouillon (which is usually 1 packet or 1 cube), bay leaf
    30 min, 13 ingredients
  • Mama Ks Baked Crab Cakes W Mustard Sauce Mama Ks Baked Crab Cakes W Mustard Sauce
    crab cakes, crab meat - fresh cooked or canned/drained and
    16 More
    crab cakes, crab meat - fresh cooked or canned/drained, favorite mayonnaise or mayo substitute, eggs or the equivalent in egg sub., worcestershire sauce, sweet red bell pepper, diced, scallions, chopped, celery stalk, diced, fresh parsley, finely chopped, baking powder, old bay seasoning, bread crumbs to coat, mustard sauce, mayonnaise (feel free to substitute light mayo or any mayo substitute), juice of 1 lemon, brown mustard, old bay seasoning, your favorite hot pepper sauce (optional)
    30 min, 18 ingredients
  • East Coast Crab Roll East Coast Crab Roll
    jumbo-lump crabmeat, cream cheese (do not use nonfat) and
    11 More
    jumbo-lump crabmeat, cream cheese (do not use nonfat), mayonnaise (do not use nonfat), dijon mustard, lemon, old bay seasoning, worcestershire sauce, salt & freshly ground black pepper, focaccia bread (11 x 17 inch piece, may substitute 1 similarly sized piece of lavash or pita bread, if using, cut th), mayonnaise, ketchup, old bay seasoning, limes
    15 min, 13 ingredients
  • Caesar Salad With Mini Crab Cakes Caesar Salad With Mini Crab Cakes
    shredded romaine lettuce (about 2 large heads ) and
    20 More
    shredded romaine lettuce (about 2 large heads ), red bell pepper , cut into small julienne strips (1/4-inch x1-inch), purple onion , cut into thin slices and then quartered, backfin fresh lump crabmeat (i use phillip s brand pasteurized crab meat) or 1 lb pasteurized crabmeat (i use phillip s brand pasteurized crab meat), sea salt or 1/4 tsp salt, old bay seasoning, cayenne pepper, fresh breadcrumb (not dried crumbs), dijon mustard (grey poupon), minced celery, minced yellow onions, prepared horseradish (from jar), mayonnaise (hellman s), eggs or 1/4 cup liquid egg substitute, fresh lemon juice, canola oil , as needed (for frying), cornmeal, caesar salad dressing (cardini, girard s, or ken s brands), fresh grated parmesan cheese (reggiano is best), seasoned croutons (i use drew s spicy croutons #54461), fresh parsley or 6 sprigs basil
    1 hour , 21 ingredients
  • Creamy Crab Dip Creamy Crab Dip
    i block philadelphia style cream cheese, softened (no low... and
    8 More
    i block philadelphia style cream cheese, softened (no low fat substitutes here!), pink or leg crabmeat , drained w/juice reserved, lump crabmeat, drained, old bay seasoning, water from crab, lemon juice, chives or shallots, finely diced (optional), mayonnaise, dried parsley (for garnish on top of casserole)
    45 min, 9 ingredients
  • Crab Florentine Quiche Crab Florentine Quiche
    refrigerated bread dough, grated gruyere cheese and
    10 More
    refrigerated bread dough, grated gruyere cheese, lump crabmeat, shell pieces removed and drained, chopped onion, coarsely chopped spinach, dried tarragon, old bay seasoning, ground nutmeg, pepper, evaporated skim milk, egg substitute, tomatoes, quartered (optional)
    1 hour 30 min, 13 ingredients
  • Shrimp Mushroom Alfredo Shrimp Mushroom Alfredo
    alfredo sauce mix, milk, butter, parmesan cheese, butter and
    6 More
    alfredo sauce mix, milk, butter, parmesan cheese, butter, olive oil, baby portabella mushrooms, minced garlic, shrimp, cooked and peeled , with, old bay seasoning, no yolks egg noodle substitute
    15 min, 11 ingredients




Get Your Recipe of Health!
Follow RecipeOfHealth on Facebook!
Scroll to top