44 pie surprise Recipes

  • Jacob's Apple Pie Surprise
    pastry for a double-crust 9-inch pie, apple pie filling and
    3 More
    pastry for a double-crust 9-inch pie, apple pie filling, frozen blueberries, white chocolate chips, cinnamon
    1 hour , 5 ingredients
  • Pecan Pie Surprise Muffins
    pecan pie, frozen, egg, milk and
    8 More
    pecan pie, frozen, egg, milk, unsalted butter, melted and cooled, vanilla extract, all-purpose flour, sugar, baking powder, salt, sugar, cinnamon
    20 min, 11 ingredients
  • Surprise Carrot Cake
    sugar, apple pie spice, baking powder, baking soda and
    12 More
    sugar, apple pie spice, baking powder, baking soda, butter, softened, eggs, slightly beaten, vanilla, cooking apples, peeled, cored and finely chopped (3 or 4, 3 1/2 cups), golden raisin, shredded carrot, fresh lemon juice, all-purpose flour, chopped pecans, toasted (optional), red baking apples, cored, cut into 3/2 inch wedges, butter, brown sugar
    1 hour 3 min, 16 ingredients
  • Surprise Sugar Stars
    butter, softened, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract and
    12 More
    butter, softened, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, king arthur unbleached all-purpose flour, baking powder, ground nutmeg, baking soda, salt, buttermilk, cherry pie filling, sugar, almond extract, whole milk, colored sugar , optional
    45 min, 16 ingredients
  • Pumpkin Surprise Pie
    ready-to-roll pie crusts or 1 (15 oz) package homemade pi... and
    11 More
    ready-to-roll pie crusts or 1 (15 oz) package homemade pie crusts, for double-crust pie, neufchatel cheese, at room temperature, granulated sugar, vanilla extract, egg, pumpkin puree, evaporated milk, light brown sugar, eggs, pumpkin pie spice, salt, egg, beaten with tsp water
    1 hour 20 min, 12 ingredients
  • Chocolate Surprise Marshmallow Pies
    pillsbury refrigerated pie crust , softened as directed o... and
    7 More
    pillsbury refrigerated pie crust , softened as directed on box, milk, marshmallows, semisweet chocolate, grated, hot fudge ice cream topping, fresh raspberries, fresh mint (optional)
    50 min, 8 ingredients
  • Chocolate-Cherry Surprise Cheesecake
    butter, unsweetened chocolate baking squares and
    11 More
    butter, unsweetened chocolate baking squares, sugar, divided, eggs, divided, milk, vanilla extract, divided, all-purpose flour, salt, cream cheese, softened, sour cream, semisweet chocolate baking squares, melted, canned cherry pie filling, toppings: canned cherry pie filling , sweetened whipped cream, milk chocolate kisses
    35 min, 13 ingredients
  • Amish Sauerkraut Surprise Custard Pie
    milk, drained and chopped sauerkraut, white sugar, eggs and
    3 More
    milk, drained and chopped sauerkraut, white sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, salt, pie shell
    1 hour 10 min, 7 ingredients
  • Patriot Day Mini Pies (Lunch Box Surprise)
    graham cracker pie crusts and
    3 More
    graham cracker pie crusts, strawberry jell-o gelatin dessert , small star shapes, berry blue jello gelatin , small star shapes, cool whip or 3 tbsp whipped cream
    5 min, 4 ingredients
  • Peach Surprise
    peach pie filling, water, peach gelatin (or 2 3oz package) and
    5 More
    peach pie filling, water, peach gelatin (or 2 3oz package), ginger ale, walnuts , if desire, cool whip, -thawed, philadelphia cream cheese, cinnamon
    4 hour 5 min, 8 ingredients
  • Pumpkin Surprise
    pumpkin (not pie mix), evaporated milk, eggs, sugar and
    5 More
    pumpkin (not pie mix), evaporated milk, eggs, sugar, ginger, cinnamon, yellow cake mix, butter (melted ), chopped walnuts
    21 min, 10 ingredients
  • BlueBerry Surprise
    yellow cake mix, cream cheese, sugar, powdered sugar and
    2 More
    yellow cake mix, cream cheese, sugar, powdered sugar, cool whip, blueberry pie filling
    35 min, 6 ingredients
  • Surprise Pie Dough Surprise Pie Dough
    butter (surprise), cream cheese (surprise) and
    2 More
    butter (surprise), cream cheese (surprise), vanilla (surprise), flour
    20 min, 4 ingredients
  • Surprise Cake Surprise Cake
    white cake mix (or whatever you like...see below) and
    2 More
    white cake mix (or whatever you like...see below), marshmallows, fruit pie filling
    30 min, 3 ingredients
  • Surprise Cherry Squares Surprise Cherry Squares
    butter (or margarine, softened), sugar, eggs, beaten and
    4 More
    butter (or margarine, softened), sugar, eggs, beaten, all-purpose flour, vanilla extract, lemon extract, cherry pie filling
    55 min, 7 ingredients
  • Mock Apple Pie Squares Mock Apple Pie Squares
    all purpose flour, sugar, salt, very cold butter and
    7 More
    all purpose flour, sugar, salt, very cold butter, sliced peeled, zucchini ( surprise surprise ), fresh lemon juice, sugar, ground cinnamon, nutmeg, chopped walnuts, golden raisins
    36 min, 12 ingredients
  • Peanut Chocolate Surprise Pie Peanut Chocolate Surprise Pie
    butter, melted, sugar, eggs, beaten, flour and
    6 More
    butter, melted, sugar, eggs, beaten, flour, peanuts, chopped, walnuts, chopped, semi-sweet chocolate chips, bourbon, vanilla extract, deep dish pie shells, unbaked
    50 min, 10 ingredients
  • Chocolate-Cherry Surprise Cheesecake Chocolate-Cherry Surprise Cheesecake
    butter, unsweetened chocolate squares, sugar, divided and
    12 More
    butter, unsweetened chocolate squares, sugar, divided, eggs, divided, milk, vanilla extract, divided, all-purpose flour, salt, cream cheese, softened, sour cream, semi-sweet chocolate baking squares, melted, canned cherry pie filling, canned cherry pie filling, sweetened whipped cream, hershey chocolate kiss (milk chocolate)
    1 hour 1 min, 15 ingredients




Get Your Recipe of Health!
Follow RecipeOfHealth on Facebook!
Scroll to top