272 fashioned sugar pie Recipes

  • New-Fashioned Pumpkin Pie
    pillsbury refrigerated pie crust , softened as directed o... and
    6 More
    pillsbury refrigerated pie crust , softened as directed on box, eggs, sugar, pumpkin pie spice, salt, pumpkin (not pie mix), evaporated milk
    25 min, 7 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Milk Pie
    unbaked pie shell, brown sugar , firmly packed and
    6 More
    unbaked pie shell, brown sugar , firmly packed, white sugar, flour, salt, cream (or 1/2 and 1/2), milk, nutmeg or cinnamon, your preference
    1 hour 10 min, 8 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Custard Pie
    cream, milk, buttermilk, white sugar, brown sugar, flour and
    4 More
    cream, milk, buttermilk, white sugar, brown sugar, flour, vanilla, egg yolks, egg whites, unbaked pie shells , 9-inch
    40 min, 10 ingredients
  • Old-Fashioned Coconut Pie
    all-purpose flour, sugar, salt, milk, egg yolks, beaten and
    5 More
    all-purpose flour, sugar, salt, milk, egg yolks, beaten, vanilla, flaked coconut, divided, baked pie crust, egg whites, sugar
    35 min, 10 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Strawberry Pie
    unbaked pie crusts, white sugar, all-purpose flour and
    4 More
    unbaked pie crusts, white sugar, all-purpose flour, ground cinnamon, fresh strawberries, hulled and sliced, butter, sugar , optional to sprinkle top
    55 min, 7 ingredients
  • Old Fashion Chess Pie
    butter, white sugar, vanilla extract, eggs, cornmeal and
    3 More
    butter, white sugar, vanilla extract, eggs, cornmeal, evaporated milk, distilled white vinegar, unbaked pie shell
    1 hour 10 min, 8 ingredients
  • Old Fashion Fudge Pie
    semi-sweet chocolate baking squares, butter, sugar and
    3 More
    semi-sweet chocolate baking squares, butter, sugar, eggs, beaten, pecans, chopped (optional), unbaked pie shells
    40 min, 6 ingredients
  • Old Fashion Pecan Pie
    butter, sugar, karo syrup, eggs, beaten, chopped pecans and
    3 More
    butter, sugar, karo syrup, eggs, beaten, chopped pecans, whole pecans (for topping ), vanilla extract, unbaked pie shells
    1 hour 10 min, 8 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Apple Pie
    unbaked pie crusts, peeled, cored and sliced apples and
    6 More
    unbaked pie crusts, peeled, cored and sliced apples, white sugar, all-purpose flour, ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg, salt, butter
    8 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Spice Pie
    white sugar, ground nutmeg, ground cinnamon and
    6 More
    white sugar, ground nutmeg, ground cinnamon, ground allspice, eggs, beaten, butter, melted and cooled, cider vinegar, vanilla extract, unbaked pie crust
    1 hour 5 min, 9 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Pecan Pie
    real maple syrup, light brown sugar , packed, heavy cream and
    6 More
    real maple syrup, light brown sugar , packed, heavy cream, molasses, unsalted butter, salt, egg yolks, pecans, toasted and chopped, unbaked pie shells, chilled
    1 hour 5 min, 9 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Fudge Pie
    butter, semisweet chocolate, sugar, eggs, pie shell
    35 min, 5 ingredients
  • Old Fashioned Cream Pie
    butter, sugar, half-and-half (cannot use 2% milk) and
    3 More
    butter, sugar, half-and-half (cannot use 2% milk), cornstarch, pie crust, prepared (baked ), nutmeg
    30 min, 6 ingredients
  • Old-Fashioned Lemon Pie
    flour, sugar, lemon , juice and rind of, butter, melted and
    3 More
    flour, sugar, lemon , juice and rind of, butter, melted, eggs, separated, milk, pie crust (either storebought or your own recipe)
    1 hour , 7 ingredients
  • Old-Fashioned Peach Pie
    ready-made pie crusts, unbaked, sugar, flour, nutmeg, salt and
    4 More
    ready-made pie crusts, unbaked, sugar, flour, nutmeg, salt, fresh peaches, sliced, lemon juice, almond extract, butter
    1 hour 35 min, 9 ingredients
  • Apple Hills Old Fashioned Apple Pie Apple Hills Old Fashioned Apple Pie
    oatmeal pie crust ,, apple juice, sugar, brown sugar and
    9 More
    oatmeal pie crust ,, apple juice, sugar, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, cornstarch, lemon juice, butter, apples, peeled and cored (golden delicious work great), milk, cinnamon, sugar
    1 hour 45 min, 13 ingredients
  • 100 Year-Old Old Fashioned Cream Pie 100 Year-Old Old Fashioned Cream Pie
    eggs , seperated, sugar, flour, salt, evaporated milk and
    3 More
    eggs , seperated, sugar, flour, salt, evaporated milk, brown sugar , packed, vanilla, unbaked pie shells
    50 min, 8 ingredients
  • New-Fashioned Apple Pie New-Fashioned Apple Pie
    all ready pie crusts and
    7 More
    all ready pie crusts, tart green apples (such as granny smith), peeled, cored,sliced, sugar, all purpose flour, grated orange peel, grand marnier or other orange liqueur, ground cinnamon, unsalted butter, cut into small pieces
    8 ingredients




Get Your Recipe of Health!
Follow RecipeOfHealth on Facebook!
Scroll to top