I make these all the time. I have tried this with different flavors of the liquid non-dairy coffee creamer and haven't found a flavor I didn't like so far. Because the fat will add up fast in this because of the amount of creamer, I opt for the fat free kind, and don't really see a big difference in the flavor. Sometimes I also put 1/4 c of the full fat, and 1/4 of the fat free and mix together. It really just depends on what I have on hand. This is easy to change around to your liking.